The political guarantees of the continuity of the federal state - Iraq is a model A comparative study

األسخاذ امىساغد امدكخِر شؤرش حسي غىر

doi:10.25212/lfu.qzj.3.1.17

Authors

األسخاذ امىساغد امدكخِر شؤرش حسي غىر ني٘ث اىلأُن / اىشآٌث اىفيٍ٘اُ٘ث

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25212/lfu.qzj.3.1.17

Keywords:

Guarantees, recognition, legitimacy, constitution, federalism, right of selfdetermination, integration, continuity.

Abstract

The federal state is based on some of the basic principles and foundations through them the regions contribute effectively to the institutions of the federal government and the success or collapse of the federal state, based on the defending of these principles and foundations through the establishment of various guarantees, including legal, judicial and political. In this study, we attempted to study the entitled "Political Guarantees for the Continuation of the Federal State - Iraq as a Model", which has a greater role in this area than other guarantees. And dealt with in two sections the first section we devoted to the study the foundations of the federal state, including the federal government's priority to the governments of the regions, the recognition of the authority of the self-report of the regions, and finally the distribution of sovereign competencies between federal and regional levels of government, the second part was devoted to the study of realistic guarantees for the success and sustainability of the federal union, including the building of the state. Federalism on the basis of choice and free will, and the foundations and principles of democracy, and finally the effective participation of the regions in the federal government. We have reached a set of results, the most important of which is that the Iraqi federal experience will not move towards continuity and stability because it emerged mainly from the needs of the interim or convictions of circumstantial one side or that, as well as the absence of democratic bases and principles fully governing institutions in the federal Iraq, which will lead to disintegration and collapse.
As we have reached some proposals, among them, the proposal to amend the Constitution in a way that includes an explicit text on this union between the federal units with freewill and choice. As well as the adoption of the Constitution in one of its basic articles against the bodies and individuals to resist cases of violation of democratic principles set out in it, and the organization of the Council of the Union in terms of composition and jurisdiction of the text of the Constitution in such a way as to ensure the initial achievement of autonomy and participation of the Territories, and ensure the contribution of the Regions to any amendment to the federal constitution either directly Or indirectly, so that the federal government will not be able to make the amendment without the consent of the regions.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

.د. اةؽاًْ٘ دروٗق، اىػوىث- ُِؽٗخٓا وحٍِِ٘ٓا، دار اىِٓيث اىٓؽة٘ث، 1969.

.د. اةؽاًْ٘ ْتػ اىٓؾٗؾ ك٘طا، اىًِِ اىف٘اـ٘ث – اىػول واىطهٌٔات، دار اىِٓيث اىٓؽة٘ث، 2006

.د.اضفان اىٍفؽسٖ، د.نٍؽان زغ٘ؽ ٍُٓث، د .رْػ اىشػة ,اىِِؽٗث اىٓاٌث فٖ اىلأُن اىػـخٔري واىِِام اىػـخٔري فٖ اىٓؽاق،اىٍهختث اىلأُُ٘ث،ةغػاد،1990.

.د.إـٍاْ٘و ٌؽزة، اىلأُن اىػـخٔري، دار نادر، ة٘ؽوت، 1969.

.د.إـٍاْ٘و اىغؾال، اىػـاح٘ؽواىٍؤـفات اىف٘اـ٘ث،ٌؤـفث ْؾاىػَٗ ىيٍتاْث واىِلؽ،ةٖروت،1996.

.د. ضفَ٘ ْرٍان ٌطٍػ ْرٍان، اىًِِ اىف٘اـ٘ث،ط1ٌِ،لٔرات اىطيتٖ اىطلٔك٘ث، ة٘ؽوت ، 2006.

.د.عاىػ كتاُٖ، اىالٌؽنؾٗث وٌفأىث حٍت٘لٓا فٖ ىتِان ،ط 1ٌِ،لٔرات ْٔٗػات ،ة٘ؽوت ،1981.

.د. ْادل اىٍتٍتائٖ، اىخِام االحطادي فٖ االٌارات اىٓؽة٘ث اىٍخطػة، ٌٍتٓث اىلاْؽة اىشػٗػة، 1978.

.د.ْتػاىطٍ٘ػ اىٍخٔىٖ،اىلأُن اىػـخٔري واألٍُِث اىف٘اـ٘ث،ج1،ط4،داراىٍٓارف االـهِػرٗث، 1966.

.د.ْتػ اهلل إـٍاْ٘و اىتفخاُٖ،ٌؼنؽات أوى٘ث فٖ اىلأُن اىػـخٔري،ٌٍتٓث اىؽاةٍث،ةغػاد ،1951.

.د.ـٓػ ْهفٔر، اىلأُن اىػـخٔري، ط1 ،دار اىٍٓارف ةاالـهِػرٗث، 1954.

.د. كٔرش ضفَ ٍْؽ، ٌٍ٘ؾات اىِِام اىفػراىٖ فٖ اىٓؽاق، ٌِلٔرات انادٍٗ٘ث اىخْٔ٘ث وحأْ٘و اىهٔادر،اىفيٍ٘اُ٘ث، 2012.

رضً٘ كاـً،اىِِام اىف٘ػراىٖ فٖ اىٓؽاق وحٔزّٗ اىفيٍات، اىٍؽنؾ اىٓؽةٖ ىخٍٔٗؽضهً اىلأُن واىِؾاْث،2006.

زْ٘ؽ ناًُ ْتٔد، اىِلاط اىٍٍٓث فٖ اىػـخٔر اىٓؽاكٖ اىػائً، ٌؤـفث ضٍػي ىيٍتاْث واىِلؽ، نؽدـخان اىٓؽاق، 2005.

.د.زْ٘ؽ كهؽ، اىٔـً٘ فٖ اىلأُن اىػـخٔري، ج1،ط3 ،اىٍؤـفث اىشآٌ٘ث ىيػراـات واىِلؽ واىخٔزّٗ، 1994.

.د.ٌٍّٓ اىشؽف، ُِؽٗث اىػوىث واألـؿ اىٓاٌث ىيخًِِ٘ اىف٘اـٕ ،اىلاْؽة ،1964.

.د.ٌاسػ راغب اىطئ ،الًُِ اىف٘اـ٘ث واىلأُن اىػـخٔري،ٌِلاة اىٍٓارف,اإلـهِػرٗث,2005.

.د. ٌطٍػ رفٓج ْتػاىْٔاب، االٍُِث اىف٘اـ٘ث، ٌِلٔرات اىطيتٖ اىطلٔك٘ث، ة٘ؽوت-ىتِان، 2007.

.د.ٌطٍػ ناٌو ى٘يث،اىًِِ اىف٘اـ٘ث –اىػوىث واىطهٌٔث ،دار اىِٓيث اىٓؽة٘ث ،ة٘ؽوت ،1969.

.د.ٌطٍػ ٍْاوُػي، اىفػراى٘ث واىطهً اىؼاحٖ واىالٌؽنؾٗث اإلدارٗث واإلكيٍ٘٘ث، ط2ٌ ،ؤـفث ٌٔنؽٗإُ ىيٍتاْث واىِلؽ،أرة٘و، .2001

ٌ .طفَ ـٓػون نؽنؽى، اىفػراى٘ث فٖ اىٍشخٍٓات اىٍخٓػدة، ط1ٌٍ ،تٓث آزادى، دْٔك، 2008.

.د.ٌهٍفٕ أةٔ زٗػ فٍٖٓ,اىِِؽٗث اىٓاٌث ىيػوىث،دار اىٍٍتْٔات اىشآٌ٘ث,اإلـهِػرٗث,1997

.د. ٌِؼر اىلاوى، اىلأُن اىػـخٔري- ُِؽٗث اىػوىث، ٌِلٔرات ٌؽنؾ اىتطٔث اىلأُُ٘ث، ةغػاد، 1981.

.د. ُؾّٗ رْػ، اىلأُن اىػـخٔري اىٓام، اىٍؤـفث اىطػٗرث ىيهخاب، ٌؽاةيؿ- ىتِان، 2008.

.اىلاىٖ ُت٘و ْتػاىؽضٍَ اىط٘اوي، حٓػٗو اىػـخٔر فٖ اىػوىث االحطادٗث، ط1 ،اىٍهختث اىلأُُ٘ث، ةغػاد، 2004.

.د.فؤاد اىٍٓار،اىًِِ اىف٘اـ٘ث واىلأُن اىػـخٔري،ج1 ،دار اىِٓيث اىٓؽة٘ث،اىلاْؽة ،1962.

.د.ذؽوت ةػوي، اىًِِ اىف٘اـ٘ث- اىهخاب االول، ط1 ،دار اىِٓيث اىٓؽة٘ث، 1961.

.د. وض٘ػ رأفج و د. واٗج أةؽاًْ٘، اىلأُن اىػـخٔري، اىٍٍتٓث اىٓهؽٗث، ٌهؽ، 1937

.د.ٗٔـف ٌطٍػ ْت٘ػان، ٌتادىء اىٓئم اىف٘اـ٘ث ، ط 2 ، كٍؽ ،1996

.دٗف٘ػ ْ٘يػ، ٍُاذج اىػٍٗلؽاٌ٘ث ( I I ،( حؽسٍث : فاىو ةهؽ، ٌٓٓػ اىػراـات االـخؽاحش٘ث،ط 1 ،ةغػاد-أرة٘و- ة٘ؽوت،2007.

.الري داٍُٗٔػ،اىػٍٗلؽاٌ٘ث - حٍٔٗؽْا وـتو حٓؾٗؾْا، حؽسٍث : فٔزٗث ُاسٖ ساـً اىؽفاْٖ، ةغػاد، دار اىٍأٌٔن ىيخؽسٍث واىِلؽ، 2005.

سٔرج أُػرـَ، اىفػراى٘ث :نخاب حٍٓ٘ػى ،حؽسٍث: ٌِخػى االحطادات اىفػراى٘ث،2007.

.ةٔي روةؽت و فػرٗم نارل، دراـات فٖ اىػوىث األحطادٗث، حؽسٍث: ةؽْان دسإُ ،ج 1ٌ، ؤـفث فؽاُهيَ٘ ،ة٘ؽوت ،1964.

روُاىػ ل.واحؿ,االٍُِث اىف٘ػراى٘ث ,ٌِخػى االحطادات اىف٘ػراى٘ث ,اوحاوا,2006

.د. كٔرش ضفَ ٍْؽ، ضاالت اىخٍٓ٘و اىػـخٔري فٖ اىػـخٔر اىٓؽاكٖ ىٓام 2005 ،ةطد ٌِلٔر فٖ ٌشيث سآٌث نّٔٗ، اىٓػد)23 ،)ضؾٗؽان 2013.

ـٔالف ٌطٍػ أٌَ٘، حٔزّٗ اىهالض٘ات فٖ اىػوىث اىفػراى٘ث ،رـاىث ٌاسفخ٘ؽ ٌلػٌث اىٕ ني٘ث اىلأُن – سآٌث نالح اىػَٗ ،2006.

.د.ٌطٍػ ٍْاوُػي، اىػوىث اىفػراى٘ث، ٌشيث ـؽدم اىٓؽةٖ، دار ـؽدم ىيٍتاْث واىِلؽ، اىفيٍ٘اُ٘ث- نؽدـخان اىٓؽاق، اىفِث األوىٕ، اىٓػد)2 ،)2003.

ٌٍٓ .ؽ ٌٓػي ناىص اىهت٘فٖ، حٔزّٗ االعخهانات اىػـخٔرٗث فٖ اىػوىث اىفػراى٘ث، اٌؽوضث دنخٔراه ٌلػٌث اىٕ ني٘ث اىلأُن/ سآٌث ةغػاد 2007.

.د. نالح ست٘ؽ اىته٘هٖ، أُفهال اىٔضػات اىٍهُٔث ىيػوىث اىفػراى٘ث، ةطد ٌَ كٔر فٖ ٌشيث اىٍطلق اىطيٖ ىيٓئم اىلأُُ٘ث واىف٘اـ٘ث، اىٓػد اىراُٖ، اىفِث اىغاٌفث.

.د.ُٔري ٌاىتاُٖ، حشارب فٖ اىِِام اىفػراىٖ، ٌشيث اىرلافث اىشػٗػة، اىٓػدان)10 و11 )اىفِث)40 ،)1994.

.د. ْادل اىٍتاٌتائٖ ، االـخلالل اىؼاحٖ ىٔالٗات اىػوىث اإلحطادٗث ، ٌشيث اىطلٔق واىلؽٗٓث، اىفِث اىؽاةٓث، اىٓػد األول،نفؽ 1400ِٗ اٗؽ 1980

.دـخٔر اىٔالٗات اىٍخطػة األٌؽٗه٘ث ىٓام 1787

.اىػـخٔر االـتاُٖ ىٓام 1978

.اىػـخٔر اىفٔٗفؽي ىٓام1999.

.اىػـخٔر االىٍاُٖ ىٓام 1949.

.اىػـخٔر االـتاُٖ ىٓام 1978.

.كأُن أدارة اىػوىث اىٓؽاك٘ث ىيٍؽضيث األُخلاى٘ث ىٓام 2004.

.اىػـخٔر اىٓؽاكٖ ىٓام 2005